Appeal Playbooks
One book for Original Medicare, one for Medicare Advantage. Each walks you from the notice in your hand to the document you send, and comes with fill-in templates in Word and PDF.
The price counts toward a Medterpret Annual plan or a Single Claim bought within 60 days. To use the credit, sign in to Medterpret with the same email address you give at checkout. The credit is then taken off for you.
Launch price through December 31. Full price from January 1.
The Original Medicare Appeal Playbook
What your plan says, what it means, what to do next. 2026 Edition.
For people on Original Medicare (the red, white and blue card), and the family members who handle the paperwork, when Medicare denies a lab test, a scan, or another service, or a lab sends a bill.
Why this matters
- 2 percentThe share of denied Original Medicare claims that were appealed to the Medicare contractor in 2025. Part B alone had about 89 million denied claims that year.Source: CMS, Original Medicare claim appeals data, calendar year 2025.
- $0What you owe on a “not reasonable and necessary” denial if the provider never had you sign a valid Advance Beneficiary Notice. The provider “is not permitted to bill the beneficiary.” Not for services Medicare never covers, such as a routine physical checkup; you owe those even without an ABN.Source: Social Security Act §1879 and §1862(a)(7); 42 CFR §§411.400 to 411.406; Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 30 (§20.2 for routine physicals). Quoted language from the Medicare contractor Noridian.
What is inside
- A 60-second triage: the reason on your notice, your 120-day clock, and the first move.
- The ABN rules, quoted from Social Security Act §1879 and 42 CFR §§411.402–411.406, and the steps to take when a lab bills you for a denied test.
- Coding errors: when to ask for a reopening first and when to appeal now, with 42 CFR §405.980 quoted.
- The five appeal levels, with CMS’s 2025 figures for Level 1 and Level 2 and exactly who they count.
- What to do when your doctor won’t write a letter: your records rights under 45 CFR §164.524.
- A chapter for caregivers doing this for a parent, and where to find free help.
- A document index that maps each situation to the right document in the Medterpret library.
Included: The book (Word and PDF) plus the Original Medicare fill-in templates from our document library, in Word and PDF. Templates have blanks for you to fill in. The price counts toward a Medterpret Annual plan or a Single Claim bought within 60 days.
See the roadmap free (the Original Medicare Roadmap, PDF, no sign-in)
$12.49 Full price $24.99One-time purchase.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare, CMS, HHS, or any government agency. This is not legal advice and our products are not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. You decide what to send.
The Medicare Advantage Appeal Playbook
What your plan says, what it means, what to do next. 2026 Edition.
For people with a Medicare Advantage plan, and the family members who handle the paperwork, when a plan says no to a lab test, a scan, or another service.
Why this matters
- 52.8 millionThe number of prior-authorization decisions Medicare Advantage insurers made in 2024, about 1.7 for every enrollee. 7.7 percent were denied in full or in part, about 4.1 million denials.Source: KFF analysis of CMS contract-level data, 2024.
- 80.7 percentOf Medicare Advantage prior-authorization denials that were appealed, the share overturned fully or partially at the plan’s own first review in 2024. The rate has been above 80 percent every year from 2019 through 2024.Source: KFF, 2024 data. This is a rate of appealed denials, not of all denials, and not a rate for the independent second review.
What is inside
- A 60-second triage: which notice you have, which deadline applies, which document to use.
- The 60-day reconsideration deadline, quoted from 42 CFR §422.582(b), with a worked example.
- The coverage floor (42 CFR §422.101 and CMS-4201-F), and how to compare a plan’s denial with Medicare’s own coverage rules.
- Prior-authorization timeframes, and when a plan must give a fast decision, in the regulation’s words.
- Two denials, two clocks: what to do when both the prior authorization and the claim are denied.
- The five appeal levels, with the published figures for Level 1 and Level 2 and exactly who they count.
- Network problems, out-of-network bills, the 90-day transition period, step therapy, and a chapter for caregivers.
- A document index that maps each situation to the right document in the Medterpret library.
Included: The book (Word and PDF) plus the Medicare Advantage fill-in templates from our document library, in Word and PDF. Templates have blanks for you to fill in. The price counts toward a Medterpret Annual plan or a Single Claim bought within 60 days.
See the roadmap free (the Medicare Advantage Roadmap, PDF, no sign-in)
$12.49 Full price $24.99One-time purchase.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare, CMS, HHS, or any government agency. This is not legal advice and our products are not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. You decide what to send.
Both books
The Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage playbooks, with both sets of templates.
$19.50 Full price $39One-time purchase.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by Medicare, CMS, HHS, or any government agency. This is not legal advice and our products are not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. You decide what to send.